Jamal Khashoggi has an interesting article translated on today’s Al Arabiya TV website and in Arabic at Al-Hayat newspaper. He takes a look at ISIS and sees it as a “third-generation” takfirist/salfist movement. He sees its origins in Egypt of the 1990s. I’d put it earlier, if not with the 1979 takeover of the Grand Mosque in Mecca, then at least in the 1980s, with the conflict between Muslim Brotherhood associates and the Syrian government in Hama. There, the Syrian government succeeded in (bloodily) suppressing the group. This time around, it’s not being terribly successful.

Khashoggi is right in pointing out that you don’t fix a problem or cure a disease until you have a correct diagnosis and understand the cause. There is far too much refusing to look for, look at, or otherwise identify the causes, but they are known. Treating the symptoms may make things look or feel better for a time, but that does not solve the problem. Nor do $100 million dollar donations to talk about the problem.

How can we defeat ISIS if we don’t understand it?
Jamal Khashoggi

The Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) has been digging its own grave, just as it has irrationally led many to their graves. It did not disappoint all those who followed its rise and predicted the inevitability of its end, as it carried the seeds of its own destruction within itself.

Last year, I published an article entitled “What history teaches us about Syria’s extremists.” At the time, ISIS was emerging in Syria and rebelling against those involved in the revolution. It was like an uninvited guest. I wrote about a story that took place in the Indian continent in the 18th century; the story of a young fighter who became the Emir of Peshawar after the success of the Islamist corrective movement to liberate the city from the rule of the “Maharajah” in just two months.

After the imposition of hardline provisions by the new emir on the tribal population of the region, they rebelled against him and brought back the Sikhs and their army to rule again. They did not rebel against the emir alone but against the whole movement, and its spiritual leader.

August:25:2014 - 10:47 | Comments & Trackbacks (1) | Permalink
One Response to “Causes for ISIS?”
  1. 1
    Solomon2 Said:
    August:25:2014 - 13:25 

    I’m pretty sure the Syrian People’s Assembly has said it all: “that Israel with its terrorist crimes against the Arab people and the Islamic and Christian holy sites has laid the foundation for the terrorism which is now sweeping across the region and threatening all its social, religious, and ethnic components.”

    Once you accept that Israel, regardless of the facts, must be regarded as a terrorist than you also accept that truth, justice, and history are all things to be bent and manipulated by the strong to oppress the weak.

    After 1956 the West saw Israel as the Dutch boy with his finger in the dike holding back the tide of tyrants; after 1967 France, judging Israel strong enough, joined with Britain and abandoned open support of Israel in favor of reaping the benefits of increased trade and cheap Muslim immigrant labor by siding with Israel’s enemies. After the 1973 oil crisis France led the way in pulling the rest of the E.U. into the anti-Israel orbit.

    Now tyrannical militancy is undermining both European societies and their post-colonial regimes. What to do from here is a good question – but how can they figure out that the problem is the values they failed to assert if they won’t acknowledge that this was the problem in the first place, since the result would favor Israel over the perceived sensibilities of 1.5 billion Muslims?

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

antalya escortizmir escort
  • Advertising Info

    Interested in sponsoring Crossroads Arabia? Contact me for more information.

  • Copyright Notice

    All original materials copyright, 2004-2014. Other materials copyrighted by their respective owners.

    The fact that this blog permits one to use RSS to read content does not constitute permission to republish content. All requests for republication must be submitted through the Contact form on the menu above. Violations of copyright will be dealt with through applicable law.