Bassam Youssef, “Egypt’s answer to Jon Stewart”, takes to Al Arabiya TV to lament the way Islamic TV shows seem to lose their way once they get past their introductions. Once they get the obligatory Quranic recitation out of the way, the floodgates are open to malicious gossip, always couched in phrases to avoid legal actions against libel. Nothing is sacrosanct: they’ll impugn an opponent’s sexuality, his family, his mother… anything to score points.

Youssef wonders if this is really “Islamic”, or even if it’s entertaining. What it unmistakeably is, though, is politics.

The Islamic gossip show
Bassem Youssef

When you watch the so-called Islamic channels, you realize you are confronting a new type of media in Egypt. It is, as they say,conservative and religious media aiming to put people on the right path. You can tell this by watching the first few seconds of a show’s introduction, which is void of music as it is forbidden. Instead, they use human voices that are digitally altered. Then a sheikh appears and begins to calmly read Quranic verses.

However, it is only a few minutes before the atmosphere changes entirely. Following a thoughtful religious introduction, the host and his guests engage in a conversation that may last until dawn, gossiping and discussing affairs linked to people’s reputations.

They may go as far as spreading rumors against their political rivals. They use expressions such as “I was told”, “someone told me,” or “someone swore to me” that “this man is gay, that man’s wife, daughter and mother did this and that.” It seems that talking about people’s reputations is their favorite spicy topic. Why talk about someone’s actions and statements when you can talk about his wife, mother and daughter?

These people claim to possess spiritual, moral and religious superiority. If you have lost your moral sense, how can you claim that you are here to guide people towards virtuous morals when your communication skills have descended to a level lower than that of your opponents? Is this the Islamic media you preach about? Is this the Islamic society you are teaching about? Is that it? Gossiping and mocking? How is this any different than the immoral programs you attack?

May:31:2013 - 07:59 | Comments & Trackbacks (4) | Permalink
4 Responses to “Argument through Innuendo and Gossip”
  1. 1
    Andrew Said:
    May:31:2013 - 13:28 

    This is quite true, and quite amusing.

    I find especially disturbing, though, the reality that so many of these shows have governmental backing.

  2. 2
    John Burgess Said:
    May:31:2013 - 17:21 

    @Andrew: I think all you need to get government funding for things like this is a good pitch and a letter or two from some senior cleric. I sincerely doubt that anyone in government actually monitors the content to see whether the money is being well-spent.

  3. 3
    Andrew Said:
    June:02:2013 - 05:01 


    You are right, but the government does have a sense of what is in these shows.

    I regularly hear from relatives who enjoy watching these shows about some point discussed.

    And our government functionaries also have such relatives.

  4. 4
    John Burgess Said:
    June:02:2013 - 08:36 

    @Andrew: I’m sure that’s true. It doesn’t seem, though, that the government officially takes notice. I mean, that’s fine as far as free speech rights are concerned — the more viewpoints the better — but the government doesn’t have to continue paying salaries to clerics who are contradicting government policy, especially when the government is acting to curb extremism.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

antalya escortizmir escort
  • Advertising Info

    Interested in sponsoring Crossroads Arabia? Contact me for more information.

  • Copyright Notice

    All original materials copyright, 2004-2014. Other materials copyrighted by their respective owners.

    The fact that this blog permits one to use RSS to read content does not constitute permission to republish content. All requests for republication must be submitted through the Contact form on the menu above. Violations of copyright will be dealt with through applicable law.