In recent comments, there’s been a bit of a discussion about separation of church and state in the US and how it affects schools. The piece below, again from Volokh Conspiracy tells the interesting tale of a recent US district court opinion. A school district—apparently without intention—created a ‘public forum’ within its classrooms by permitting teachers to post signs and the like expressing (if not out-and-out promoting) religious and philosophical views. Having done so, it could not (as it did) prohibit the expression of some views while permitting the expression of other views:

A Rare First Amendment Victory
for a Public School Teacher Complaining
About Restrictions on In-School Speech

Generally a public school has broad authority over what teachers say in class. When they’re teaching, or counseling students, they are seen as speaking on behalf of the school, and the school has broad power to control its own speech. And schoolteachers generally have no constitutional right to put up materials of their own on the walls, since those are the school’s walls, for the school to dispose of as the administration pleases.

But Johnson v. Poway Unified School Dist., decided yesterday by the federal district court for the Southern District of California, is a rare exception: The judge concluded that the school district had created a designated public forum for teacher speech, by allowing teachers to put up pretty much any posters they please in their classrooms, including:

The comments to the post at Volokh are generally interesting as well. Some are from the archly anti-religious; others from those more neutral on the subject. One link from a comment goes to an interview with Christopher Hitchens I think worth reading in full. In it, he discusses how the US is unique in having a constitution that draws a clear line forbidding the establishment of a state religion.


February:27:2010 - 10:05 | Comments & Trackbacks (1) | Permalink
One Response to “Church, State, School”
  1. 1
    Swedish Said:
    February:27:2010 - 15:16 

    The old saying goes” Teach not Preach”. Unfortunatly, some do not understand or distinguish the differences between teaching “about” religion and “preaching” religion. I witnessed, much to my dismay, the Ten Commandments on a wall of first grade classroom back in the United States. Along with the Ten Commandments were video tapes on the teachers desk about Moses. This is fine, at PRIVATE religious school, not a public one.

    On the otherside of the spectrum, students are allowed to congregate and have religious groups, as long as it around the parameter of school grounds. Unlawfully so, the students got reprimmanded for having this religious meeting.

    I think it refreshing to know, that, yes, no preaching, but school teacher can wear h/her religious garb and likewise, so can the student. Just no preaching.

    Here in Turkey, wearing a veil is strickly prohibited. Some of friends here asked about professor in states who covers herself is lawful and I explained that it surely is legal. Certainly took some time the explaining the logic behind the legalities.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

spacer
  • Advertising Info

    Interested in advertising on or sponsoring Crossroads Arabia? Contact me for more information.

  • Copyright Notice

    All original materials copyright, 2004-2013. Other materials copyrighted by their respective owners.

    The fact that this blog permits one to use RSS to read content does not constitute permission to republish content. All requests for republication must be submitted through the Contact form on the menu above. Violations of copyright will be dealt with through applicable law.